Behavioral Ecology

Female-female competition is increasingly recognized as a key driver of female ornamentation, including birdsong, which often functions in intrasexual competition. However, the specific resources females use elaborate traits to compete for remain unclear. In addition, few studies have simultaneously investigated the use of multiple competitive traits in females, despite growing independent interest in these traits (e.g., female song and aggression). We investigated the competitive contexts of female song, aggression and calling behavior in northern house wrens (Troglodytes aedon) to determine which resources females compete for across the breeding season. We simulated conspecific territorial intrusions using female song at three breeding stages representing different contexts: arrival (mate and territory acquisition), nest building (nest site and breeding status defense), and egg laying (brood defense). We tested whether female song and physical aggression varied as reproductive resources shifted across the breeding cycle. Females were significantly more aggressive during nest building, showing 5.8 times greater odds of a higher-intensity aggressive response during nest building compared to arrival. Female song output was similar across early stages but declined during egg laying, though this was not statistically significant after correction for multiple comparisons and individuals varied substantially in overall singing propensity. Non-song vocalizations varied by call type and breeding stage. Calls associated with aggression occurred most frequently during nest building, consistent with peak physical aggression responses. Together, these results identify nest building as the stage of highest female aggression, consistent with heightened competition over nest cavities and associated breeding status in this cavity-nesting species. In contrast, female song occurred across all stages and appears to function in multiple competitive contexts. This study provides evidence for context and mode-specific female signaling in a temperate songbird and highlights that females strategically use aggression, calls, and song to mediate social conflict across breeding contexts.

The social complexity hypothesis for communication posits that species with elaborate social systems require more sophisticated vocal communication to navigate social life. Geladas (Theropithecus gelada), who live in complex multilevel societies and form diverse social bonds, are ideal for testing this hypothesis. Males produce species-specific, or derived, calls that reflect social status and function in facilitating male-female bonding. However, although derived call use also occurs in male-male social interactions, their function in male-male communication remains unexamined. In this pilot study we investigate the use of derived calls within a captive all-male bachelor group and test two hypotheses: (1) derived calls signal bachelor dominance status, and (2) derived calls function to maintain male-male social bonds. Despite a limited sample size, our results show that bachelor leaders produce higher proportions of derived calls than bachelor followers, mirroring patterns found in harem groups. Furthermore, bachelor followers were most likely to use derived calls in affiliative and resting contexts, suggesting a role in social bonding. In contrast, bachelor leaders used them more broadly. They additionally produced derived calls during agonism and travel, thereby possibly reflecting their more elaborate leadership duties. These findings provide the first preliminary evidence that derived calls serve functions beyond male-female communication and may be integral to both status signalling and affiliative interactions among bachelor males. Our results on the vocal dynamics in male geladas shed further light on the co-evolution of social and vocal complexity and offer broader implications for the origins of human language.

1. Adaptive behavioural strategies require animals to simultaneously navigate social and ecological domains across multiple spatial and temporal scales. Although drones and computer vision have recently transformed the study of wild animal societies, many nocturnal species and those occupying structurally complex habitats remain inaccessible to these approaches, limiting our understanding of behaviour in natural settings. 2. We aimed to determine how behavioural strategies are organised across nested spatial and temporal scales within a wild communication network. 3. We used three-dimensional acoustic localisation and source separation to track individual male Hyperolius sp. A, a nocturnal African reed frog, within a natural rainforest chorus and quantify patterns of site fidelity, movement, spatial organisation, and call-timing interactions. 4. Males exhibited significant site fidelity across nights, while chorus spatial structure varied with local caller density. Within nights, individuals followed a stereotyped behavioural sequence, descending from elevated arboreal refugia before settling into lower calling positions near breeding sites. At finer temporal scales, call-timing interactions varied according to both local competitor density and the proximity of neighbouring rivals. 5. These findings demonstrate that behavioural strategies emerge across nested spatial and temporal scales and that long-term spatial positioning, short-term movement decisions, and moment-to-moment signalling interactions are tightly linked within natural communication networks. More broadly, acoustic localisation provides a powerful framework for studying behaviour in species and habitats that remain difficult to observe using conventional approaches.

Environmental predictability influences the value of information acquired through experience, yet relatively little is known about how instability in resource characteristics influences behavioural organisation during foraging. We tested whether repeated changes in floral orientation, a manipulation of environmental predictability, affect pollen foraging in bumblebees (Bombus terrestris) by exposing naive workers to either stable floral conditions (single flower orientation) or repeated inter-trial changes in flower orientation (three alternating flower orientations), under constant resource availability. We quantified pollen collection, foraging efficiency, revisitation behaviour, floral coverage and sonication behaviour across three successive foraging trials of either constant or variable flower orientation, before assessing performance in a common post-treatment preference test in which bees were offered all three flower orientations and higher pollen rewards. Environmental instability altered the organisation of foraging behaviour. Bees exposed to unstable floral conditions progressively reduced flower revisitation behaviour and were less likely to perform sonication, although floral coverage, defined as the number of unique flowers visited, remained unchanged. Contrary to our predictions, instability had only weak immediate effects on pollen acquisition and foraging efficiency compared to bees tested under stable conditions. However, previous exposure to instability generated carry-over effects in the common post-treatment preference test. Bees previously exposed to unstable conditions were significantly less likely to return with pollen and consequently collected less pollen overall than bees previously exposed to stable conditions. Our results demonstrate that environmental instability can influence pollen foraging in ways that are not captured by immediate measures of performance. Although behavioural adjustments appeared to buffer short-term consequences during repeated foraging trials, carry-over effects were evident when bees were later tested in a common high-reward, multi-orientation floral array. These findings highlight the importance of considering both behavioural flexibility and carry-over effects when evaluating how organisms respond to changing environments.

Social animals must identify, evaluate, and appropriately respond to other individuals, often relying on multiple sources of information to guide context-dependent behavior. While individual recognition is thought to be widespread and critical for many social interactions (e.g. territoriality, dominance hierarchies), convincing demonstrations across animals beyond class-level recognition remain rare. Further, the cues animals use to recognize individuals remains poorly understood, especially in natural environments where they are exposed to numerous cues which may require cue integration. Here, we examine how socially dominant males of the African cichlid fish, Astatotilapia burtoni, use individual recognition to modulate aggression and whether this process depends on the spatial context. Using naturalistic experimental setups, we exposed males to familiar and unfamiliar neighbors while systematically manipulating spatial location and presenting a neighbor either singly or simultaneously to simulate competing social cues. Additionally, we measured circulating testosterone to assess endocrine correlates of recognition and aggression. We found that focal males habituated to familiar neighbors only when they remained in a consistent territorial location, demonstrating that spatial context is important for recognition. Further, when familiar and unfamiliar neighbors were presented simultaneously, males preferentially aggressed toward unfamiliar rival and adjust their aggressive response to the perceived threat of their neighbors, indicating that identity-based threat assessment is maintained under competing social demands. Together, our results show that recognition is a flexible, multi-faceted process that depends on the integration of identity and contextual information to guide territorial decision-making under dynamic social conditions.

Allee effects are positive relationships between components of individual fitness and the number or density of individuals in a population. Negative density effects are well documented in Drosophila melanogaster across life stages, while Allee effects are rare and largely confined to the larval stages. However, despite the costs of high density, adult flies are found to exhibit attraction to same-sex conspecifics, suggesting some fitness value to the presence of conspecifics. We measured fitness related traits of singly mated-females housed at same-sex densities of 1, 2, or 10 and found clear reductions in lifetime reproductive output at low densities. Additionally, these females concentrated reproductive effort within early adulthood, albeit without improving estimates of fitness. When housed at variable densities, females altered their reproductive output in response to immediate densities, but were unable to improve it unless remating was possible, indicating an interaction between mating and density. Overall, our findings suggest that reproductive plasticity in response to the presence of conspecifics mediates positive effects of density on fitness in female Drosophila melanogaster. Understanding the physiological and ecological bases of such plasticity may help explain the evolution of social tendency in the fly.

Schooling is a widespread behaviour among pelagic fish that reduces locomotion costs of migration and predation risk. It is characterised by coordinated movements, speed and orientation of group members. Although schooling can vary both between populations and among individuals of the same population, these levels of variation are seldom considered together. Here, we investigated whether schooling tendencies in three-spined sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) vary between populations and among individuals within-populations depending on their phenotype. We first compared the schooling behaviour of anadromous (migrants) and recently landlocked (residents) populations and tested whether individual sociability explained within-population variation in schooling. We then studied whether schooling behaviour is modulated when migrants and residents are in mixed groups. Migrant groups displayed better schooling performance than residents with higher alignment. Within migrant groups, less social individuals displayed more leadership, were better aligned, swam closer to others and fatigued less than more social fish. These patterns were absent in residents. When the two populations were mixed, overall schooling performance declined, particularly in migrants, with schools exhibiting reduced compaction and alignment, resembling resident groups. Thus, individuals did not modulate their schooling behaviour to the group social composition and phenotype-dependent schooling patterns were disrupted in migrants when mixed. These findings suggest that migration-related behaviours can disappear quickly post-isolation. They also highlight the importance of individual sociability in self-organisation and shaping collective behaviour, especially in populations that retain migratory behaviour. Considering behavioural variation across multiple hierarchical levels is thus key to understanding complex social systems.

Animals face a fundamental trade-off between food-related competition and predation risk in how they allocate time and behavior. Nocturnal mammals offer a particularly tractable system for testing this trade-off because moonlight creates a natural, quantifiable gradient in both predation risk and the visibility needed for safe movement. We used minute-by-minute focal observations of nine kinkajous (Potos flavus; 4 female, 5 male) in Panama to test how fruit abundance and moonlight predicted nocturnal activity budgets (percent time traveling, feeding, resting) and nightly travel distance. Beta-family generalized linear mixed models and a linear mixed model of log travel distance showed that fruit abundance was positively associated with percent time traveling and with nightly travel distance, and negatively associated with percent time feeding: kinkajous traveled more and fed less per hour when fruit was abundant, consistent with movement between many nearby productive trees rather than prolonged feeding at a few. Males traveled less as moonlight increased, while females traveled more. Rainfall had no independent effect. We interpret the sex-reversed moonlight response as evidence that moonlight elevates predation risk for males while facilitating movement for the more food-limited females of this frugivorous carnivore.

Reproductive success often depends on coordinated combinations of morphology, dispersal ability, and mating behavior. Supergenes, genomic regions of suppressed recombination, allow such combinations to be inherited by offspring as a single unit. In ants, independently evolved supergenes control colony queen number, yet few studies have investigated their joint influence on morphology, mating, and colony-founding in sexuals. Formica cinerea provides a unique opportunity to address this question because it harbors two supergenes that together produce three queen and male morphs: large monogyne, large polygyne, and small polygyne. Here we show that these supergenes jointly shape an integrated suite of traits across the reproductive cycle. Wing area was primarily associated with the chromosome 3 supergene, with monogyne individuals having larger wings than polygyne individuals. Thorax volume was associated with the chromosome 9 supergene, with small polygyne individuals having reduced thorax volume regardless of social origin. Mating was assortative for both supergenes in large morphs but random in small polygyne queens. Independent colony founding was almost exclusively performed by large monogyne queens; initial egg production was unaffected by mate genotype. These findings show that the two supergenes jointly coordinate dispersal morphology, mate choice, and colony-founding into coherent reproductive strategies, preventing maladaptive intermediate phenotypes.

Individual variation in singing behavior is influenced by cultural evolution, environmental constraints, and population dynamics. In closed-ended songbird species, aging may be associated to temporal song variations in individual birds due to vocal apparatus deterioration. However, song variations may also arise as a result of extrinsic factors that induce behavioral changes. In this study, we aimed to examine song-type consistency over 13 years in four populations of the White-eared Ground-sparrow (Melozone leucotis, Aves: Passerellidae) along an urban-rural gradient. We also compared within and between-individual variation to determine potential population-level responses. We used long-term data from singing males to quantify five fine structural characteristics (minimum frequency and maximum frequencies, bandwidth, peak frequency, and song duration) for two most common song types from each population. Song consistency differed between fine-structure characteristics, song types, and populations. Contrary to our expectations, we found that the Highly urbanized population had greater between-individual variance, associated with anthropogenic disturbances such as habitat structure and noise pollution, suggesting non-uniform individual responses. The Medium, Low urbanized, and Rural populations, on the other hand, had higher levels of within-individual variance, associated to individuals' age. Our study brings insight into how both intrinsic and extrinsic factors can influence song consistency and highlights how cultural evolution within a species can diverge across populations experiencing distinct environmental contexts.

Colony defence is critical for the survival of wild honeybees but presents a challenge for local populations and beekeepers. Apis mellifera scutellata is an important pollinator in its native range, a large area of Southern and Eastern Africa 1, but is reputed for its explosive temperament. Here, we present data demonstrating that this behaviour is only exhibited by a small fraction of colonies, while others are relatively docile. This sheds new light on this subspecies and on its likely evolutionary trajectory. We further characterize the different elements of this defensive response and compare them to that of A. m. carnica and A. m. mellifera. We show that each subspecies invests differently in the two steps of the behavioural sequence (alert and attack). Furthermore, our results suggest that the task of attacking is carried out by specialized workers in carnica, but not in the other subspecies tested, highlighting subtle differences in colony organization across subspecies. Finally, we discovered that defenders from A. m. scutellata and scutellata-hybrid colonies can locate a target that was stung up to 2 h and 3 h earlier, respectively, whereas European bees could only do so for 30 min. This long-term marking could confer an advantage against returning predators with few weak points, such as honey badgers and humans wearing protective clothing. Overall, we offer a fresh perspective on this controversial but important subspecies of honeybees, with implications for both future studies and daily management.

Chorus howls play a central role in wolves' (Canis lupus) social communication, shaping both intra- and inter-pack interactions. While synchrony has been shown to influence perceived threat from outgroups in birds and humans, whether the synchrony of an outside pack's chorus howl plays a role in wolf pack behaviour remains unclear. This study investigated behavioural responses of 19 zoo-housed wolf packs to playbacks of synchronous and asynchronous chorus howls from unfamiliar packs, in comparison to a dove control call. We hypothesized that packs would show stronger intra-pack cohesion and greater spatial withdrawal in response to more synchronous, and thus cohesive - and potentially more formidable - sounding vocalisations. Alternatively, asynchronous howls might elicit stronger responses due to their ambiguity and the "Beau Geste" effect (where asynchronous signals make it harder to infer the number of callers). Synchronous howls resulted in more distance from the sound source and less activity compared with asynchronous howls. This could be interpreted as a more cautious response towards a perceived threat. However, since there was no effect on pack-directed behaviour and no difference between the synchronous and control sound, lower interest or motivation to engage with the stimulus cannot be excluded. In contrast, wolves spent more time near the sound-source after hearing asynchronous howls, approached it more, and oriented towards it for longer compared to synchronous playbacks, a pattern consistent with threat-investigation. In how far these reactions result from a more difficult localisation of synchronous howls or more ambiguity in pack size in the asynchronous playbacks, as well as how this translates to wild wolf behaviour, remains to be investigated.

Across species, changing environmental conditions are altering major phenological milestones. In seasonal environments, this can involve shifts in the timing of activity onset, growth, reproduction, and senescence; however, predicting these responses can be challenging and often requires species-specific information. In this study, we investigated phenological patterns of bumble bee colony development using observations from wild nests of two common species, Bombus griseocollis and B. impatiens. Using observations of nest traffic, we documented dates of nest-searching, peak worker activity, first gyne (new queen) production, and colony senescence over three years of field data collection. We also tested whether colony growth was density dependent, because longstanding life history models have shown that colony growth patterns determine the optimal timing of reproduction in constant environments. Here, we present a novel extension of these models, using them to infer that density-independent colony growth should be associated with extended phenology in warmer years, while density-dependent should have consistent phenology. In total, we found 79 wild nests, including 34 reproductive colonies (19 B. griseocolis and 15 B. impatiens). Bombus impatiens colonies were larger, had a longer activity period, and showed density-independent growth and later reproduction in warmer years, while B. griseocollis colonies were smaller, shorter-lived, and showed density-dependent growth and similar dates of reproduction across years. Both species had higher gyne production in warmer years. These results highlight the role of life history theory for predicting interspecific variation in phenological changes, as well as a research framework for exploring possible evolutionary mismatches of existing life histories in changing environments.

Animals often display active decision-making while navigating noisy habitats, for varied purposes like foraging, finding shelter, evading predators or finding suitable mates. While some responses are hardwired, following fixed action patterns, others are more flexible, and display context-dependent plasticity. Animals might weigh behavioural consistency against adaptive plasticity when facing recurrent ecological difficulties, but the nuanced mechanisms orchestrating this balance is not well understood. We investigated this question by repeatedly exposing 47 free-ranging dogs to chicken contaminated with lemon solution, an aversive but edible and familiar food source, across four consecutive trials. By integrating behavioural frequencies, latency measures, feeding efficiency, interaction-time and location effects, repeatability analyses, and behavioural sequence structure, we examined how repeated experience influenced foraging behaviour. Contrary to expectations of broad behavioural reorganisation, most behaviours remained stable. Initial approach latency was strongly repeatable within individuals with no detectable influence of sex or trial number across the population. This suggests that how an animal first assesses risk is primarily shaped by stable personality traits rather than momentary external factors. Eating behaviour and bowl nudging also changed selectively across exposures, with modest sex differences in several behaviours. Behavioural sequences became increasingly similar over time, while several behaviours retained consistent individual differences, indicating persistent behavioural tendencies. Our results collectively demonstrated that repeated aversive exposure selectively modified a few critical decision points rather than the entire behavioural repertoire. This implies that animals can adapt by making small adjustments to specific behaviours while maintaining the stability of their overall behavioural architectures. Animals seem to assess risk separately from how well they use resources. That separation may help explain how stable personalities can coexist with the fast, flexible decisions animals need in unpredictable environments shaped by humans.

Sexual interactions involve the exchange of information-including olfactory, auditory, and visual cues-that has been shaped by sexual selection to maximize fitness. While these courtship signals and behaviors are often characterized as stereotypical and species-specific, male courtship is plastic and can depend on the population identity of the courted female. The ability of a male to adjust his courtship behavior based on female identity has significant implications for how selection operates on courtship, potentially driving behavioral divergence between populations and the eventual emergence of new species. A major challenge is identifying the cues that males use to adjust their courtship strategy. We used Drosophila melanogaster to investigate the mechanisms facilitating courtship plasticity, focusing on male song production. Male song is often considered the paramount behavior performed by males and is stimulated by female pheromones. Previous observations have focused on cosmopolitan (non-African) genotypes, whereas the singing rate and singing plasticity is highly variable in African populations. In genotypes from Zimbabwe, females have a different major pheromone compound (5,9-HD) compared to non-African females and show strong behavioral preference for Zimbabwe males. We created a Zimbabwe genotype lacking 5,9-HD by disrupting the gene desat2 in the Zimbabwe Z53 strain. We tested the hypothesis that Zimbabwe male courtship plasticity depends on female pheromones by allowing males to court non-African, wild type Z53, and Z53 desat2 null mutant females. We found that males treated Z53 desat2 null females like wild type Z53 females, not using pheromone cues to determine singing and courtship plasticity. This suggests that other female behavioral feedback influences singing plasticity. This courtship plasticity could contribute to the asymmetrical reproductive isolation between these populations and could provide insight to the broad pattern of asymmetrical reproductive isolation across broad taxonomic groups.

Social relationships can buffer individuals against environmental challenges, reducing the physiological costs of disturbance. Assessing how social and environmental conditions jointly shape physiological stress is critical for predicting individual responses to disturbance, particularly in managed populations. We evaluated whether social and environmental stressors act additively or whether social context modifies physiological responses to environmental challenges. We combined behavioural data and faecal glucocorticoid metabolite samples from a small, intensively monitored population of African elephants (Loxodonta africana) in a fenced reserve. Using a Bayesian framework, we tested how social factors interacted with variation in the biophysical environment, including natural environmental and anthropogenic disturbances, to predict glucocorticoid concentrations. Natural environmental variables, including weather, water availability, and season, did not predict glucocorticoid concentrations. In contrast, helicopter use, a common management intervention, was associated with higher glucocorticoid concentrations. Social effects were context dependent. Following disturbance, low-ranking individuals showed higher glucocorticoid concentrations than high-ranking individuals, whereas this pattern reversed under low-disturbance conditions. Individuals with more social connections had lower glucocorticoid concentrations, but this effect was evident only under non-disturbance conditions. Measures of betweenness centrality did not predict glucocorticoid levels. These results demonstrate that social factors mediate physiological responses to anthropogenic disturbance and that management actions can impose uneven physiological costs across individuals. Quantifying interactions between social factors and the biophysical environment may improve conservation and management strategies for social species. Integrating physiological responses to interactions between social factors and the biophysical environment can guide conservation strategies and improve management interventions in social species.

When individual preferences for collective outcomes diverge, cohesive animal groups often coalesce on the majority opinion. However, majority-based decision rules may be counterbalanced by other factors, particularly in heterogeneous groups with differentiated social relationships, and these factors could produce inequality in social influence. We used multi-sensor tracking collars to collect detailed and simultaneous data on the movements and vocalizations of almost all members of three wild white-nosed coati (Nasua narica) groups, and analyzed 2,401 individual decisions between conflicting travel directions. Decision-making was shared: individuals favored directions that had majority support, and we found evidence that they used acoustic signals and movement cues to infer majority support. Individuals were also more likely to choose directions favored by closer kin and by groupmates in more frontward spatial positions. Although decisions were shared, influence was not equally distributed across individuals. During directional conflicts, individuals who were more likely to form majorities or who were advantaged by frontward spatial positions had higher influence over travel direction. By explicitly linking decisions by individual followers to emergent patterns of influence among potential leaders, our results suggest that influence is a complex product of higher-order interactions that are likely dependent on group demography and socio-spatial structure.

Human-influenced environments pose challenges but also provide wildlife with anthropogenic resources. Individuals vary widely in their ability to exploit such resources, often as a function of behavioural type. However, we lack a clear understanding of how variation in behavioural traits influences stages of resource exploitation required to use anthropogenic resources. Using fully automated foraging puzzles, we examined how boldness and sociability influenced three aspects of resource exploitation - discovery, problem-solving, and overall performance - in two wild populations of California ground squirrels (Otospermophilus beecheyi). Bolder individuals discovered the resource earlier, solved the task faster and achieved higher performance, indicating that boldness promotes efficient exploitation of anthropogenic resources across multiple stages in the process. Greater sociability and more opportunities to observe conspecifics solving the task led to faster problem-solving, consistent with evidence for observational learning. Squirrels in the recreational-use population - with regular exposure to humans and anthropogenic food - were faster to discover the resource than those in a trail-use population - where human exposure was transient and no anthropogenic food available. Problem-solving latency and performance were consistent between populations. Our findings highlight how individual variation in behavioural traits drives performance in novel ecological contexts, providing a mechanistic understanding of behavioural plasticity in human-influenced environments.

Mobbing is a collective antipredator behaviour in which animals approach and harass a threat while coordinating signals to alert conspecifics, recruit allies, or deter predators. In group-living Arabian babblers (Argya squamiceps), snake mobbing involves two distinct signals: acoustic "zwick" calls inaudible to the snake and visual wing-lifting displays. We elicited snake-mobbing events with dummy vipers and recorded babbler groups using a synchronized acoustic camera enabling individual caller identification and postural analysis. Our results reveal the different and similar roles of the two signals in babblers' multimodal mobbing behaviour. Recruitment order was independent of sex, age and rank. Individual investment in mobbing signaling decreased as group size increased, supporting the hypotheses of social buffering and predation risk dilution. Solitary individuals always called during wing-lifts, supporting the calls' recruitment function. Mobbing individuals responded faster (with signaling) to a joint visual-acoustic conspecific display than an only acoustic signal. When coupled, wing-lifts significantly altered vocal characteristics, decreasing call frequency and increasing call rate, thus strengthening the acoustic signal. Moreover, calls emitted toward the end of the wing-lift display exhibit stronger vocal modulation. Together, these findings demonstrate the multi-functional role of multi-modal mobbing signals during a risky cooperative task balancing social communication and predator deterrence.

Sexual reproduction is widespread despite being less efficient than asexual reproduction. While its long-term evolutionary benefits are well recognized, it remains unclear why facultative sex, which should allow lineages to balance the advantages of both sexual and asexual reproduction, is not more common. One potential reason is that intermittent sex imposes novel costs compared to obligate sex, limiting the persistence of facultatively sexual lineages and constraining introgression. We test this possibility using the sexually polymorphic aphid parasitoid wasp Lysiphlebus fabarum. We reared offspring from females who reproduced asexually or by facultative sex for three generations (without sex after the founding generation). We genotyped F1 females to confirm facultative sex and used antennomere number, a phenotypic marker associated with reproductive mode, to test whether mixed sexual-asexual genotypes could be tracked across generations. We found multiple barriers to facultative sex. Mating did not always result in offspring with sexual-asexual genotypes, and when sex did occur, broods were usually comprised of asexually and sexually produced offspring. Additionally, lineages founded by females produced through facultative sex showed reduced fecundity compared to asexually produced broods. We saw declining frequencies of the sexual antenna phenotype in the generations after facultative sex, suggesting that genotypes generated by facultative sex are selected against. Overall, our results provide empirical support for the idea that facultative sex can impose costs that persist beyond the initial sexual event. These costs, together with low realised rates of sex, may limit long-term introgression and explain why facultative sex appears rare compared to obligate sex.